After a second full day of hearings, San Diego County planning commissioners voted four to three to recommend approval of the Lilac Hills development west of Valley Center. The development would build 1,700 homes in a semi-rural area zoned for about 100.
The approval comes with a series of conditions.
Commissioner Douglas Barnhart, (appointed by Supervisor Bill Horn) outlined the conditions, which include building or expanding a fire station to meet the rule that firefighters should be able to reach a fire within five minutes.
Secondly, the developer should pay to build a new school at a location to be determined in consultation with the Bonsall Unified School District.
Third, the developer must build the village center before more than 1,000 of the 1,700 homes planned are built.
A number of conditions were also set to avoid exercising eminent domain to widen the road connecting the project to Interstate 15.
Commissioner Peter Norby (Dave Roberts appointee) opposed the project, along with Michael Beck (Dianne Jacob appointee) and Michael Seiler (Greg Cox appointee). Norby said that approving the project will blow a hole in the County’s General Plan that is going to sink it.
Following the vote, the developer, Accretive Investments, put out the following statement:
“We’re very pleased that the commission weighed all the factors and came to the conclusion that Lilac Hills Ranch will be a tremendous development for the community of San Diego. We’re looking forward to next month’s County Board of Supervisors vote and trust that we will have a similar outcome.
What this shows is that when a developer works with County staff and listens to the wishes of the community, great things can be accomplished.”
"I am disappointed that four planning commissioners failed to understand the broader implications of approving this project with all its apparent flaws.
This new standard, which has not been vetted by the public, will be invoked by a long line of projects, waiting to see this result. It could mean large, sprawling projects all over the county.“